Subscribe to SIAWI content updates by Email
Home > Uncategorised > Jerusalem for Dummies: Why the World Doesn’t Recognize It as Israel’s (...)

Jerusalem for Dummies: Why the World Doesn’t Recognize It as Israel’s Capital

Wednesday 6 December 2017, by siawi3

Source: https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/1.826929

Jerusalem for Dummies: Why the World Doesn’t Recognize It as Israel’s Capital

And why the possibility that Trump might do just that, seven decades after Israel’s establishment, is such a source of apprehension worldwide

David B. Green

Dec 06, 2017 10:50 AM

Photo: The Israeli flag flutters in front of the Dome of the Rock mosque and the city of Jerusalem, December 1, 2017.

Red lines and severed ties Trump’s looming Jerusalem embassy decision sparks diplomatic fallout
Israel fires back at Turkey: Jerusalem has been the Jewish capital for 3,000 years
Trump delays final decision on moving U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem, White House says

Jerusalem is holy to three religions. Jerusalem is a powder keg, and the smallest wrong move there could set off a religious war. The Arab-Israeli conflict will never be solved until the Jerusalem question is resolved.

Yes, these are all truisms, and you’ve heard them a thousand times or more. But there’s a reason why the root of the word “truism” is “true.” For Jews, Jerusalem is where their Temple – the home of their one god – stood, in its various incarnations. Each time they were exiled from their cultic and political capital in ancient times, they dreamed of returning, and the term “Zion,” the name of one of the city’s hills, became a metonymy not only for the city itself, but for the Land of Israel in general, and the basis of the name of the modern movement calling for establishment of a Jewish state there.

>> How Jerusalem went from hosting 16 embassies to zero <<

So, why don’t the nearly 160 countries that have diplomatic relations with the State of Israel recognize Jerusalem as its capital, and why is the possibility that the United States may do just that now, nearly seven decades after Israel’s establishment, a source of such apprehension worldwide?

FILE PHOTO: Israeli soldiers approach the Dome on the Rock June 7,1967 on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, Israel on the day of its capture from Jordanian forces in the June 1967 Middle East War.
FILE PHOTO: Israeli soldiers approach the Dome on the Rock June 7,1967 on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, Israel on the day of its capture from Jordanian forces in the June 1967 Middle East War. Newsmakers / Getty Images / Staf

Jerusalem trivia: Think you know everything there is to know about Israel’s capital? Prove it

The answer has to do with that first truism – the importance of Jerusalem to Christianity and Islam, which between them have more than 3 billion followers worldwide. For Christians, Jesus, their messiah, died in Jerusalem and came back to life there; they can trace his genealogy back to King David, who established the united monarchy in Jerusalem and whose descendants, according to the Hebrew Bible, will include the Messiah.

For Muslims, Jerusalem – specifically “the farthest mosque,” identified with Al-Aqsa Mosque – was the destination of the Prophet Mohammed on his Night Journey, from where he ascended to heaven to speak with God.

>> Trump delays final decision on moving U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem, White House says <<

For each of these religions, there is a spot in the Old City of Jerusalem that is most sacred, and it is the focus of their strongest, deepest passion and commitment: For Jews, it is the Holy of Holies, whose precise location is no longer known, making the entire Temple Mount holy ground; for Christians, it is Calvary, where Jesus was crucified, which, for a majority of followers, is situated in what is today the Church of the Holy Sepulchre; while for Muslims, Al-Aqsa has come to refer to the entire Haram al-Sharif (the Arabic name for Temple Mount).

Photo: The UN vote on the partition of Palestine, 1947. GPO

The early Zionist leaders, many of whom were secular, were ambivalent about Jerusalem. Theodor Herzl himself envisioned the capital of his Jewish state being on Mount Carmel, in the north. In his 1989 book “Jerusalem: City of Mirrors,” Amos Elon describes how Herzl, and also cultural-Zionist theorist Ahad Ha’am and a young David Ben-Gurion, among others, were all discomfited by the city and Jews’ connection to it; Elon also quotes historian of Zionism Anita Shapira, who, characterized the feelings of the Zionist pioneers toward the city as no better than “reactionary.”

When the United Nations, on November 29, 1947, gave its imprimatur to a plan to divide Palestine into two states, one Arab, one Jewish, it famously left Jerusalem (which at the time had a large Jewish majority) out of the equation, intending it and its surroundings (including Bethlehem) to become an internationally administered, separate territory – a corpus separatum. The Jews accepted the plan, and Ben-Gurion noted that the loss of Jerusalem as part of sovereign Israel was the “price we have to pay” for a state in the rest of the land.

When the Arabs rejected the Partition Plan, and launched a war on Israel, the latter no longer considered itself bound by the boundaries set by the UN plan. During its War of Independence, Israel improved its strategic position in most parts of the country, and in Jerusalem, when the cease-fire lines were drawn, Israel occupied the western part of the city and the Jordanians the city’s east, including the Old City, where the Western Wall and Temple Mount are situated. Israel had fought for Jerusalem, and now it was not about to give it up.

Officially, the UN stuck with its internationalization plan after the war, but both Israel and Jordan preferred to leave the city divided. A no-man’s land ran through the center of the city, and a barrier, and passage from one side to the other was severely limited. If the city had been under international control, everyone would have had access to all of its parts, including the holy sites.

Although attempts were made by Jordan and Israel to come to an agreement on Jerusalem, both sides also took unilateral steps that made it unlikely that agreement would be reached. Israel annexed West Jerusalem to its territory on December 5, 1948, and declared the city its capital a week later. Jordan followed by annexing East Jerusalem on December 13, and it also named Jerusalem as a second capital, although it remained a very neglected second capital up until the Six-Day War.

Photo: Rally of Israeli American Republicans in support of Donald Trump in Jerusalem, October 26, 2016.

Under the situation prevailing during the 19 years between statehood and the 1967 war, an uncomfortable status quo prevailed in Jerusalem. So long as that situation persisted, and Israel remained in a state of war with the Arab world, no agreement was going to be reached about Jerusalem. And so long as the two sides to the conflict could not decide on the city’s future, the United Nations was neither going to take sides nor attempt to impose a solution on them. Hence, the question of Jerusalem remained open, and officially, the city was not recognized as part of either Israeli or Jordanian territory. This was not to say that foreign diplomats would not come to Jerusalem to meet Israeli officials, but just that recognizing it as Israel’s capital, or setting up an embassy there, was tantamount to prejudicing any future political settlement.

Then came the Six-Day War, when Israel took possession of Jordanian Jerusalem, and expanded the city’s boundaries in the north, east and south to take in a number of Arab neighborhoods that had not historically been part of metropolitan Jerusalem. Over the years, Israel has moved all of its government offices to the city, placing many in the eastern section, it has carried out extensive residential construction along lines intended to make its hold on all of the city difficult to reverse, and it has adopted a number of political policies that almost guarantee that even a left-wing government would not be able to cede any of Jerusalem to a Palestinian state.

In recent decades, everyone’s position has hardened. Clearly, the world community could not give a hand to Israel’s unilateral steps in East Jerusalem, nor its so-called facts on the ground, in the form of tens of thousands of apartments in new, Jewish neighborhoods in the east. And the Palestinians appear not to be ready to compromise on the condition that the capital of any future state be situated in East Jerusalem.

Although Israelis and Palestinians have been negotiating off and on, and more and less seriously, for more than 25 years, talks on Jerusalem have never gotten very far. And so long as the sides cannot decide on a mutually agreeable plan for sharing sovereignty in Jerusalem, or on any other arrangement there, nor has the world community concluded that it must impose a solution on the sides – it would be highly improbable for any individual state to unilaterally give official recognition to Jerusalem as its capital.

Any individual state, that is, not led by Donald J. Trump.

David B. Green

Haaretz Columnist

You Might also Like

The biggest loser in Trump’s high-stakes Jerusalem embassy decision: Netanyahu Haaretz | Opinion The biggest loser in Trump’s high-stakes Jerusalem embassy decision:…
Moving U.S. embassy to Jerusalem only requires new sign on consulate building, city officials say Haaretz | News Moving U.S. embassy to Jerusalem only requires new sign on consulate building…
Theresa May’s epic ’Saturday Night Live’ debut breaks the internet Haaretz | News Theresa May’s epic ’Saturday Night Live’ debut breaks the internet

Here’s the Inside Scoop of What Really Goes on Behind Closed Cruise Ship Doors From The Web DestinationTips.com Here’s the Inside Scoop of What Really Goes on Behind Closed Cruise Ship Doors
This City-Builder Game lets You Play through the Ages From The Web Forge Of Empires This City-Builder Game lets You Play through the Ages
From The Web Lenovo FR Lenovo ThinkPad E570 15.6 SMB Laptop

Recommended by
skip all comments
Comments

Sign in to join the conversation.

Gone Viral
Trending Now

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu arrives to attend the weekly cabinet meeting at the Prime Minister’s office in Jerusalem December 3, 2017.
Opinion The Biggest Loser in Trump’s High-stakes Jerusalem Embassy Decision: Netanyahu
An Israeli air force F-15, at the Ovda air force base, on November 8, 2017.
With Syria Strikes, Israel Shows It’s Willing to Risk a New Front With Iran
Israel border police forces patrol near the Western Wall and Al-Aqsa/Temple Mount compound on December 5, 2017.
Analysis Trump Set to Recognize Jerusalem - but Don’t Panic Just Yet
Border Police officers walk past a souvenir shop displaying a T-shirt bearing an image of Trump dressed as a Hasidic Jew, in Jerusalem’s Old City, December 4, 2017.
Jerusalem Crisis Palestinians Declare Three ’Days of Rage’ Over Trump Embassy Decision

Jerusalem Temple Mount Donald Trump

Trending Now

Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman attends a graduation ceremony and air show marking the 50th anniversary of the founding of King Faisal Air College in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, January 25, 2017.
Analysis The Saudi King Has a Problem: The Crown Prince
By Zvi Bar’el1 hour ago This is a primium article
Israeli security forces patrol a street in the East Jerusalem refugee camp of Shoafat, where a home was demolished earlier the same day, December 5, 2017.
Analysis Ahead of Trump’s Embassy Announcement, Israel Girds for Violence in Jerusalem and West Bank
By Amos Harel3 hours ago This is a primium article
President Donald Trump speaks about his decision to shrink the size of Bears Ears and Grand Staircase Escalante national monuments on December 4, 2017.
White House Confirms: Trump to Recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s Capital, but Delay Embassy Move for Now
By Amir Tibon (Washington)8 hours ago
The Najran Fort today, Saudi Arabia: Early Christians in the city of Najran were persecuted by the Himyarites, leading some to speculate that the Himyarites couldn’t have been true Jews.
Before Islam: When Saudi Arabia Was a Jewish Kingdom
By Ariel David29.11.2017 25 comments 25
A satellite photo shows the extent of damage caused by the alleged Israeli strike on an Iranian military base in Syria
Before and After Aftermath of Alleged Israeli Strike on Iranian Base in Syria, Revealed
By Haaretzyesterday

Promoted content

a brand new Penthouse in Gordon St >>>
Beautiful quiet and peaceful Cottage with a magnificent garden >>>
High standrard apartment in the north of Tel Aviv >>>

Sunset in Jerusalem, 2015
Trump, Take Note: How Jerusalem Went From Hosting 16 Embassies to Zero
By David B. Green1 hour ago
A file photo of Linda Sarsour during a convention in Detroit, Michigan, U.S., October 27, 2017.
Sarsour at anti-Semitism Panel: ’I Am the Biggest Problem of the Jewish Community?’
By Asher Schechter29.11.2017 This is a primium article 7 comments 7
Steve Bannon and Morton Klein.
Steve Bannon’s Best Jewish Friend
By Dina Kraftyesterday This is a primium article This article contains a video

Security & Aviation

File photo: An Egyptian air force fighter jet landing at an undisclosed location in Egypt.
Russia: Egypt Will Allow Us to Deploy Military Planes on Its Soil
A file photo of a North Korean intercontinental ballistic missile, Hwasong-14, in July 29, 2017.
Kim Declares North Korea ’Responsible Nuclear Power’ After Launching New Missile That Can Reach U.S. East Coast
The Sufi mosque west of the North Sinai capital of El-Arish after a gun and bombing attack, Sinai, Egypt, November 25, 2017.
Analysis Astonishing Egyptian Failure Has Israel Worried
File photo: Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah gestures during a rally in a southern suburb of Beirut, Lebanon, 2013.
’Hezbollah’s Nasrallah Is a Target’ in Next War, IDF Spokesperson Says

Subscribe to Haaretz today
Now: save 25%

Sponsored Content

The Way Jack Nicholson Spends His Millions Is Totally Awesome Work+Money The Way Jack Nicholson Spends His Millions Is…
10 TV Stars Who Earn More Than Bollywood Actors CriticsUnion 10 TV Stars Who Earn More Than Bollywood Actors

Ivanka Trump Cuts Asking Rent for Manhattan Condo to $13,000 Mansion Global Ivanka Trump Cuts Asking Rent for Manhattan Condo…
Les nombreux mystères de Ask LLC et Moise Katumbi washtimes Les nombreux mystères de Ask LLC et Moise…

By
ICYMI
The Najran Fort today, Saudi Arabia: Early Christians in the city of Najran were persecuted by the Himyarites, leading some to speculate that the Himyarites couldn’t have been true Jews.
Before Islam: When Saudi Arabia Was a Jewish Kingdom
A file photo of Linda Sarsour during a convention in Detroit, Michigan, U.S., October 27, 2017.
Sarsour at anti-Semitism Panel: ’I Am the Biggest Problem of the Jewish Community?’
Jack Hadfield is seen in a screenshot of his Facebook account.
Breitbart Writer Exposed as Admin of White Supremacist Facebook Group
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry shakes hands with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (R) during a news conference following a meeting at Netanyahu’s office in Jerusalem December 5, 2013.
Israel, Egypt Pushed U.S. to Bomb Iran Before Nuclear Deal, John Kerry Say
U.S. President Donald Trump and President Vladimir Putin in Danang, Vietnam November 11, 2017
Trump ’Revealed Israeli Commando and Mossad Operation’ in Syria to Russians
Hagar Ben-Asher, director of "The Slut" and "The Burglar."
How an Acclaimed Israeli Director Ended Up on Death Row
Dr. Günter Bechly.
A Respected Scientist Comes Out Against Evolution – and Loses His Wikipedia Page
Rudi Weissenstein
The Year Is 1936. A Man Picks Up a Camera, Captures an Israel That’s No More
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman
Saudi Arabia: Israel’s Dream State
FILE PHOTO: This photo provided on Friday Oct. 20, 2017 by the government-controlled Syrian Central Military Media, shows Iran’s army chief of staff Maj. Gen. Mohammad Bagheri, left, looks into binoculars as he visits the Iranian military near Aleppo, Syria.
Syria Deal Puts Iran Too Close to Israel’s Borders
Stella Penn Pechanac.
Former Israeli Soldier Identified as Harvey Weinstein’s Spy
The sundial
2,000-year-old Sundial Changes Perception of Ancient Rome
File photo: Iran’s Revolutionary Guards testing ballistic missiles, 2012.
Explained Who Wants a War in the Middle East? Seven Key Players and Their Interests
Gorny Muscovite Russian church in Ein Karem, jerusalem.
Rare Beauty Picturesque Christian Pilgrimage Site in Jerusalem in Danger
Roger Waters performs ’The Wall’ in its entirety at the Wells Fargo Center November 8, 2010 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Is Roger Waters a Peace Activist or an anti-Semite?
Illustration by Adi Emanuel
Special Report: What the Jewish Federations Do With Your Money
This undated photo provided by St. Charles County Department of Corrections via KMOV shows Sayfullo Saipov, the suspected driver in a deadly truck-ramming attack.
What We Know About New York City Attack Suspect Sayfullo Saipov
The ancient copper mines at Timna
Is the Bible a True Story? Latest Archaeological Finds Yield Surprises
FILE - In this Nov. 22, 1963 file photo, President John F. Kennedy waves from his car in a motorcade in Dallas. Riding with Kennedy are First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy, right, Nellie Connally, second from left, and her husband, Texas Gov. John Connally, far left.
JFK Files How Oswald’s Childhood Friend Ended Up in Israel ’Helping the Mossad’
A painting of Martin Luther posting his Ninety-five Theses against the Catholic Church on the doors of the Castle Church in Wittenberg, Germany
The 500th Anniversary of the Protestant Reformation: When Faith Was Privatized

FAQ
Contact us
Newsletters
Terms and conditions
Cancellation of Digital Subscriptions
Privacy policy
Management
Editorial
Accessibility
Advertise on Haaretz.com

RSS
Contact us
Download our Android app
Download our iOS app
gPlus
Facebook
Twitter

Israel News
Middle East
Jewish World
U.S./World
Business
Partnerships
Dan Hotels in Tel Aviv
Israrel Real Estate
Haaretz Labels
Today’s best deals

Life
Archaeology
Science
Sports
Culture
Purim
Books
Travel
Theater
Movies and TV
Food
Poem of the Week

Columnists
Bradley Burston
Chemi Shalev
Allison Kaplan Sommer
Anshel Pfeffer
Sayed Kashua
Ilene Prusher
David Rosenberg
Carlo Strenger
Vered Guttman
Opinion
Daily Cartoon
Letters to the Editor

הארץ
חדשות
גלריה
ספורט
ספרים
סרטים מומלצים
קפטן אינטרנט
משחקי הכס - עונה 8
יום הקולנוע הישראלי
TheMarker
חדשות
שוק ההון
צרכנות
נדל"ן
Finance
ת"א 35
מדד תל אביב בנקים 5
מניית טבע
מניית טאואר

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd. All Rights Reserved

read more: https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/1.826929