Subscribe to Secularism is a Womens Issue

Secularism is a Women’s Issue

Home > impact on women / resistance > India: We Will Not Be Silenced

India: We Will Not Be Silenced

Wednesday 16 September 2020, by siawi3


We Will Not Be Silenced: Harsh Mander’s Open Letter and Statement by Prominent Activists Expressing Support

Harsh Mander; and Aruna Roy et al.

September 6, 2020


We Will Not Be Silenced

Harsh Mander

September 4, 2020

The Delhi Police believes that there was a conspiracy behind the communal violence in Delhi during the third week of February.

We agree.

But the actual conspiracy was a very different one from the one which Delhi Police is propagating.

The truth is that not just the Delhi 2020 carnage; no major episode of communal violence is spontaneous: it is always planned, organized and facilitated.

Such violence requires first the systematic creation of hatred. In Delhi we saw the build-up during the Delhi elections of a climate of hatred spawned by hate speech by senior leaders targeting the protestors against CAA NRC NPR. This was led from the front by the union home minister, the chief minister of Uttar Pradesh and several other cabinet and BJP party leaders. The outcome was the spread of unprecedented levels of toxic communal venom, unmatched in any previous election in Delhi.

But beyond the manufacture of hatred and the organization of the violence, the critical factor in any riot conspiracy is the role of the state, and particularly the police. No riot can go on for more than a few hours except if the government wishes for it to do so.

There is massive evidence of the complicit partisan role of the police in the Delhi violence. I have spent a lot of time with the victim survivors of the Delhi carnage. I have hear hundreds of testimonies from them about the role of the police enabling, encouraging and actually indulging in hate violence.

The video of policemen tormenting four young men lying on the ground, among who Faizan subsequently died, is telling. The police while beating the men prone on the ground are taunting them by asking them to sing the national anthem; it was clear that they are punishing them for the protests, in which the national anthem had become an iconic symbol of the protests, of resistance, of unity and of solidarity.

This was the conspiracy behind the Delhi communal violence. It was a bid by the Indian state, aided by the Delhi police, to punish and crush the largest non-violent protests that independent India has seen.

The police story is quite the opposite. According to them, it was the anti-CAA-NRC-NPR protests which were the conspiracy, and that the non-violence of the protests was only a facade.

In pursuit of this story, every day the Special Branch of the Delhi Police, which normally investigates grave crimes like terror, is busy for the past months summoning mostly young people, and sometimes seniors, grilling them, intimidating them, and sometimes – as Umar Khalid has testified – forcing them create false evidence.

Large numbers of young people are today languishing in prison for months without bail in the name of this so-called conspiracy.

We are gathered here today above all in the defence and solidarity with all of these young people.

Yes, they and we did participate in the non-violent movement against CAA NRC NPR, and we are proud to have done so.

During the protests some WhatsApp groups were made. Now every word exchanged in these groups are being examined with a defective microscope by the police, their meaning and context deliberately and mischievously misinterpreted, the truth ripped into shreds and reimagined to create the mythology of a conspiracy of hate, violence and insurrection.

There were significantly other WhatsApp groups that the police themselves admit to, wherein indeed people are actively calling for and organizing the violence on those dates. None of these are being the subject to any investigation of a conspiracy.

Our protests, and those of the young people now in our prisons, were to uphold the Constitution, and the idea of an inclusive and humane country of equal citizenship, which is the proudest legacy of our freedom struggle.

The young people and we protested because we love our country dearly, and we seek to make this country better for all its citizens, of every religion, caste, class and gender, by holding the state accountable to stand by its duties to the constitution.

It is a travesty to describe this as a crime against the nation. Those who are seeking to create divisions and hate among us are those who are committing crimes against our country.

The objective of the government is transparent; to destroy the basic guarantees and freedoms of our constitution.

The effort of the Indian state, facilitated by the Delhi Police, is to crush our voices, our dissent, and our struggles to uphold our constitution.

We declare here – and hope those holding highest office in the country hear us loud and clear – that the government will never succeed in silencing us, and will never succeed in taking away from us the dream we inherited from our freedom struggle, the dream of together building a country which is just, and equal, and kind.

? ? ?

An Open Statement from the Forum for Constitutional Rights and Democratic Freedoms

The Forum for Constitutional Rights and Democratic Freedoms (FCRDF) was constituted in August, 2020, after discussion amongst its six Principal Members, comprising both individuals and organizations, all representing different constituencies. All were concerned with the erosion of constitutional rights and democratic freedoms in the last few years and came together on a common platform to stem the tide. The Principal Members are: a) Admiral (retd.) Laxminarayan Ramdas as the representative of Veterans b) Justice (retd.) Ajit Prakash Shah as the nodal person for those generally part of the legal fraternity c) Aruna Roy of Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan (MKSS) as representing people’s organizations of the poor and disadvantaged d) Deb Mukharji, IFS (Retd.), former High Commissioner to Bangladesh, on behalf of Constitutional Conduct Group (CCG), made up of retired civil servants e) Dr Ganesh Devy, scholar and close to both progressive intellectuals as well as grassroots forces and e) Githa Hariharan, writer, Indian Cultural Forum, deeply involved with literary and cultural currents.

This is our first statement on behalf of the FCRDF. We write to express our full support for the statement ‘We will not be silenced’ made by Harsh Mander on September 4, 2020. We believe strongly with him that the communal riots in Delhi in February 2020 have not been caused by any conspiracy as alleged by the Delhi Police but that on the contrary, they have been caused by the hate speeches and provocative statements made by a number of political leaders of the ruling party. We stand with him, Professor Apoorvanand and their fellow activists and believe strongly that neither their voices nor ours will be silenced as we speak for truth and freedom.

The ringing words of the last paragraph bear repetition and have our endorsement:

“We declare here – and hope those holding highest office in the country hear us loud and clear – that the government will never succeed in silencing us, and will never succeed in taking away from us the dream we inherited from our freedom struggle, the dream of together building a country which is just, and equal, and kind .”

Admiral (retd.) L. Ramdas, former Chief of Naval Staff
Justice (Retd.) A.P. Shah, former Chief Justice of Madras and Delhi High Courts and former Chairman, Law Commission
Aruna Roy, Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan
Deb Mukharji, IFS (Retd.), former High Commissioner to Bangladesh, CCG
Dr. Ganesh Devy, civil society organizations
Githa Hariharan, writer, Indian Cultural Forum