Subscribe to Secularism is a Womens Issue

Secularism is a Women’s Issue

Home > Resources > Stuart Hall in Africa - Race and class in South Africa.

Stuart Hall in Africa - Race and class in South Africa.

Monday 31 May 2021, by siawi3



South Africa

Stuart Hall in Africa

By Sean Jacobs

Race and class in South Africa.

My early university education at the then-very white University of Cape Town coincided with South Africaís transition from Apartheid to democracy. Stuart Hall didnít feature much, despite the fact that, as I would later learn, I was indirectly influenced by his ideas about identity politics, language, culture, race, and social movements.

For example, I remember writing a seminar paper as a final year student at the University of Cape Town about ďblack AfrikaansĒóa movement of coloured poets and educators in Cape Town and the Cape West Coast allied to teacher unions and the United Democratic Front who sought to counter white histories of Afrikaans by emphasizing the languageís hybrid origins in a slave economy and encouraged use of spoken working class coloured Afrikaans in classroom settings. Nevertheless, culture (or studying culture) was hardly a priority for my late-1980s/early-1990s cohortóSouth Africa then was in the midst of a violent transition; protest movements and their academic allies were tactically focused on electoral power and state institutions.

Strategic considerations, too, pushed us to eschew analyses of race in favor of class and nation. Lynette Steenveld, a media scholar at Rhodes University in South Africaís Eastern Cape, wrote to me that ďÖ identity was a problem because of the Apartheid stateís racialization of identity and its essentialist stance on culture. So the one progressive move was to eschew identity and focus on class.Ē

That said, there is ample evidence that South African scholars, students and media activists were very familiar with Hallís work in that period. In 1980s Apartheid South Africa, academics who studied culture, came at it from two diametrically opposed schools: on one side a more traditional behavioralist approach (the Afrikaans ďcommunications studiesĒ) and on the other, leftist /political economy approaches to culture (reflecting dominant positions in the liberation movement and old school Marxist influences).

But as Steenveld recently reminded me that when she was a graduate student in the mid-1980s, some scholarsómost notably at Rhodes University in the Eastern Cape and what is now the University of Kwazulu-Natalówere exposed to the work of Stuart Hall. Keyan Tomaselli, a media scholar at the now University of Kwazulu-Natal, who is most closely associated with the beginnings of cultural studies in South Africa, should take much of the credit for this. He modeled a center after Hallís at Birmingham. Steenveld adds: ďI personally came from a Marxist position which was critical of the ANCís racial politics, so discovering through Hall a new way of thinking left politics was helpful to me.Ē

In 1995, I went to study for a political science graduate degree at Northwestern University in Chicagoís northern suburbs. It is probably there where I first became familiar with Hallís work in classes on the interactions between media, globalization, and cultural politics. Not surprisingly, my current research and writing on popular culture (reality shows, public television, advertising, social media, and my foray into football studies), is heavily influenced by Hallís work.

When Hall passed away, The New York Times tried to dismiss him as a scholar and activist of multiculturalism only and suggested his influence was limited to Britain; someone who was out of time. That was, however, contradicted by how a whole new generation on social media who honored and debated his legacy. It helped that Hall reinvented himself right up until the end, speaking directly to 21st century anxieties. For example, in 2013 writing about his and othersí ďKilburn Manifesto,Ē Hall wrote: ďWhat is required is a renewed sense of being on the side of the future, not stuck in the dugouts of the past. We must admit that the old forms of the welfare state proved insufficient. But we must stubbornly defend the principles on which it was founded Ė redistribution, egalitarianism, collective provision, democratic accountability and participation, the right to education and healthcare Ė and find new ways in which they can be institutionalized and expressed.Ē

Specific to South Africa, Hall cared for and wrote about that country. His most explicit engagement with South Africa was in his 1980 essay, Race Articulation and Societies Structured in Dominance, where he entered academic debates between white South African left and liberal intellectuals over the nature of domination and repression. I am surprised not more people in South Africa have read it or commented on it. Hall, of course, eventually did get to South Africa himself in 1996, accompanied by his wife, Catherine. He gave the keynote address at a conference at the now-University of Kwazulu-Natal (invited there by Tomaselli).

I have been trying to find a copy or a transcript of Hallís address to the conference, but with no luck thus far. I keep wondering what Hall made of South Africa, still a very new country at the time of his visit. Perhaps he would have admired the South Africans for their tenacity, warned against complacency and, like Gramsci, reminded the South Africans that it is always a ďwar of position.Ē Or he may have said of South Africa, what he later said of Barack Obama. At the time Obama was elected, Hall celebrated the election of the first black president of the United States as a historic event, but cautioned that the value of Obamaís Presidency remained to be seen. Three years later, Hall felt comfortable to cast judgment: While Obamaís ďheart was in the right place,Ē he ďwas never radical.Ē Hall also felt that Obama and his supporters had not reckoned with the inertia of the American political system and its tendency to settle for a tepid consensus and was disappointed by some of Obamaís policy decisions.

But perhaps as much as his ideas, Hallís influence and prominence made a significant impression on whole generations of black intellectuals and scholars, myself included, who came of age in the 1980s and 1990s. The South African academy has always skewed white, and black intellectual role models were often rendered invisible, even where they did exist (either to exile: Archie Mafeje, Stan Nolutshungu, Bernard Magubane; or not properly acknowledged when at home, like Neville Alexander and Jakes Gerwel). What John Akomfrah and Ben Carrington wrote and said about Hallís impact on young black intellectuals in Britain holds for places like South Africa: ďThere was no space for someone like me before Hall.Ē Wrote Carrington, on Africa is a Country (a site I started and that I like to think may be an indirect part of Hallís legacy): ďItís taken for granted now that culture matters, that popular culture is a site of politics, that politics saturates everyday life, and that these things can and should be studied in a serious manner. But despite their claims, it was not Sociology, or History, or Economics, or even Anthropology that created this space. It was Cultural Studies.Ē

Finally, Hallís transparent engagement with his familyís biography, his exploration of his relationship to blackness and creole identities, provided a way of thinking about my own family history. Despite the class differences (Hall grew up middle class; Iím the son of a domestic worker and a gardener) and the different historical specificities of the Caribbean versus the Western Cape of South Africa, there were striking commonalities: Shame, slavery, colonialism, colorism, and deference to whites (despite the violent history of white trusteeship and oppression), are also ďnaturalĒ to the world in which I grew up. (For example, Hallís parents discouraged him from playing with dark-skinned children, prevented his sister from marrying a black doctor and never really identified with Jamaica.) Those are parts of my biography that I still want to explore. Perhaps the most lasting impression I have of Hallís lifeís work is that he continued working at making sense of the past and the present until the very end.

* This was first published on Social Text.

Sean Jacobs, Founder and Editor of Africa is a Country, is on the faculty of The New School and a Shuttleworth Fellow.